It was rendered superfluous in September 2004 when most of its participants joined the SkyTeam alliance.

News of the battle soon reached London, rendering superfluous a government proclamation made on the same day and which offered a rich reward for his capture.

But the truth is that Uncle Buck, the film, has been rendered totally superfluous once you've seen the trailer you have seen the film.

Opposed by Robert Persons, it was rendered superfluous by the appointment of an archpriest (1599).

Dave Magadan, rendered superfluous by the Murray signing, by himself will not bring the Mets the kind of pitcher they want.

Justice Ginsburg cited a general principle of statutory interpretation that calls for statutes to be interpreted so that no clause is rendered superfluous.

Its invocation is merely rendered superfluous.

The former Catholic parish church of Saint Cecilia's was thus rendered superfluous and was demolished.

The argument for more Europe has not so much been won, as rendered superfluous.

In effect, their hearts had been bypassed and rendered superfluous.