A three-judge panel has already ruled that the suit can go forward.

In 2008 a panel ruled in its favor on all the issues.

He said the panel would then rule on the appeal.

A three-judge panel has ruled that the jury was wrong.

The panel of judges ruled, however, that prosecutors had not proven their case.

In 1997, the city's panel ruled that the police union had to accept a contract without raises for the first two years.

For these reasons, the panel did not rule in favor of the United States.

The panel ruled that the request came too late, and kept both actors in the running.

The appellate panel usually rules about three months after oral arguments.

From its inception in 1996 through 2009, the panel has ruled on only three complaints.