In 1867 the congregation constructed a wood frame building at the corner of South State and South streets.

By January 1886, the parish had constructed a church at the corner of fourth and Putnam.

Accordingly, a small wooden sanctuary was constructed at the corner of Fourth and Carimona in 1872.

In 1873 a new church building was constructed at the corner of 23rd and Michigan.

By 1890, the Zachry Building was constructed at the corner of Main and College.

Toledo's first medical college was constructed at the corner of Cherry and Page streets, in 1896.

A new, larger, building was constructed at the corner of Centre Street and Seventh Avenue.

During these developments a small chapel was constructed at the north-west corner of the church.

In 1902, the congregation constructed its first synagogue building, at the corner of Franklin and Spruce.

A running track and a baseball field surrounded by trees have been constructed at the southwest corner.