But the city has appealed the order, saying that the police should be allowed to use discretion.

The city appealed for federal aid and got only a shadow of what it wanted.

But by noon the city had successfully appealed the order.

A state judge, however, approved the formula, and the city has appealed the decision.

The city appealed and arguments were set for this morning.

It was not clear, they said, how far the city would appeal.

The city appealed the court's ruling, but lost a 2008 appeal.

He declined to say whether the city would appeal the decision, which is to take effect Sunday.

The city has appealed the ruling, but a decision is not expected until next year.

But the city appealed and was granted a stay of the ruling.