strangely familiar

They were both big men and, for some reason, strangely familiar.

She seemed strangely familiar to him although he was certain they had never met.

She didn't recognize the deep voice on the other end, though it was strangely familiar.

The strangely familiar people in the town believe it is 1926.

It looked strangely familiar, as if he had seen something similar before.

Something about it was strangely familiar, but I can't say exactly why or how.

Something seemed strangely familiar and I gave him a closer look.

There was something strangely familiar about the scene before me.

A man whose face was strangely familiar opened the door.

There was something strangely familiar about his face, and yet I could not place him.